AnnaMagdalena 4Christ, on “WHAT IS GENDER? PART 2” (Reblog)


This post is the second in a series on What is gender? Click here to read the first post.

EDIT: I added two paragraphs on the politics of sex determination that I meant to discuss in the original post. 


Our experience of gender begins, whether we’re conscious of it or not, at birth. When the doctor pulls us from the womb, she looks at our genitals and makes an evaluation – does the child look male or female? This evaluation isn’t as straightforward as it may seem. When the doctor looks between the child’s legs, the only thing she sees is the apparent genital morphology. She can’t see the child’s chromosomes, test the child’s gonadal tissue, or perfectly predict the child’s hormonal trajectory. All she sees is whether the child’s genitals look phallic or yonic, and from that she makes a broad biological assumption. This assumption is the child’s assigned sex.

For intersex persons with ambiguous genitalia, this process of assigning a sex is thwarted because their genitals don’t read one way or the other. In a more rigorous medical atmosphere, the doctors will then do hormonal and genetic tests to check on the person’s other sexed characteristics. If they find, for example, that the person has xy chromosomes, they may assign that person a male sex even though their genitals are undetermined. This is what I calldetermined sex, the biological pronouncement made once doctors do a thorough evaluation of chromosomes and hormones as well as genitals.

Problems arise when the doctors can’t determine one single dominant sex. What if the chromosomes are mixed as well? Often times, in this situation doctors will surgically assign a sex (what we might call constructed sex), and then assign a gender.

Assigned gender is the verbal pronouncement the doctor makes after she reads the child as male or female. She pronounces it “a boy” or “a girl.” From assuming the child’s sex, she then foretells – usually correctly, but sometimes incorrectly – that child’s entire gender destiny. This pronouncement most immediately determines the child’s legal sex, the little M or F that appears on their birth certificate, which will determine their legal status in all walks of life.

For intersex people, their site of embattlement includes all the above. The doctors aren’t certain about how their sex characteristics add up, so they not only guess at the person’s sex, but also guess at the person’s gender. If a person has both xy chromosomes and a vagina, the doctors are assuming what this mix means. Is the person a single sexed thing – male or female? And can we know from their biology how they will embody those sexed characteristics – as a boy or a girl? In this case, the facts of sex are clearly in question, which throws the world of gender into question as well.

Gender breakdown intersex

[EDIT] Determined sex is largely a medical issue, although brushing it under the rug as “something for the doctors to figure out” overlooks the gender politics that overshadow intersex issues. When a doctor decides the sex of a physiologically “ambiguous” child, he never achieves complete objectivity on the issue. To choose the child’s sex, he first has to choose a theory of gender: often either based on genetics (the person is male because they have xy chromosomes), predominance (the person is female because most of their sex characteristics appear female), or convenience (the person will be made female because it’s easier to surgically create a vagina).

The underlying problem is the social pressure to immediately determine the child’s sex and “normalize” it. When a child is born sexually ambiguous, doctors, parents, and clergy often freak out and treat it as a medical emergency. This forces the medical team to make brazen decisions which often leave the child scarred from haphazard invasive surgery. When the child’s sex is undetermined, in many cases the doctors’ guess is as good as anyone’s as to whether they will grow up to be a boy or girl, and so any choice that’s made on behalf of the child is essentially Russian roulette (see the discussion in Part 3 on David Reimer). This is why many intersex activistsadvocate forgoing surgical interventions until the child is old enough to both know their gender identity and make an informed decision.

To a limited degree these problems also apply to transsexuals. There is thebiological possibility that transsexuals have a brain that is physiologically sexed as the gender they identify as. This is what I call brain sex. So we can talk tentatively about transsexuality as an intersex condition (what I call being transsexed), in which case assigned and determined sex are thrown into question. If I have a “female” brain and male genitals, why should the doctors assume that my genital sex trumps my brain sex? I think these are valid questions, although I don’t think they’re the primary site of embattlement for transsexuals. I talk about this more in the next section.

Click here to proceed to Part 3, the conversation on “gender as subconscious sex.” 


257 thoughts on “AnnaMagdalena 4Christ, on “WHAT IS GENDER? PART 2” (Reblog)”

  1. Pingback: movies
  2. Pingback: movies online
  3. Pingback: karan johar
  4. Pingback: Top Movies
  5. Pingback: Movies1
  6. Pingback: 11 10 2019
  7. Pingback: Serial smotret
  8. Pingback: kinokrad
  9. Pingback: kinokrad 2020
  10. Pingback: casino
  11. Pingback: filmy-kinokrad
  12. Pingback: kinokrad-2019
  13. Pingback: serial
  14. Pingback:
  15. Pingback: dorama hdrezka
  16. Pingback: movies hdrezka
  17. Pingback: HDrezka
  18. Pingback: kinosmotretonline
  19. Pingback: LostFilm HD 720
  20. Pingback: bofilm
  21. Pingback: 1 seriya
  22. Pingback:
  23. Pingback:
  24. Pingback:
  25. Pingback:
  26. Pingback: Evil-Season-1
  27. Pingback: Evil-Season-2
  28. Pingback: Evil-Season-3
  29. Pingback: Evil-Season-4
  30. Pingback: Dollface-Season-1
  31. Pingback: serial 2020
  32. Pingback: Dailymotion
  33. Pingback: Watch+movies+2020
  34. Pingback:
  35. Pingback: #1plus1
  36. Pingback: 1plus1
  37. Pingback: Film
  38. Pingback: Film 2020
  39. Pingback: Film 2021
  40. Pingback: human design
  41. Pingback: dizajn cheloveka
  42. Pingback: human-design-space
  43. Pingback: 2020
  44. Pingback: koma 2020
  45. Pingback: The-Gentlemen
  46. Pingback: led-2
  47. Pingback: pod-vodoi
  48. Pingback: vk 2020
  49. Pingback: DSmlka
  50. Pingback: viagra
  51. Pingback: viagra online
  52. Pingback: +
  53. Pingback: ¯jak Son³k
  54. Pingback: astrolog
  55. Pingback: generic cialis
  56. Pingback: cialis 20mg
  57. Pingback: seasonvar
  58. Pingback:
  59. Pingback: strelcov 2020
  60. Pingback: film t-34
  61. Pingback: online pharmacy
  62. Pingback: canadian pharmacy
  63. Pingback: psiholog
  64. Pingback: psyhelp_on_line
  65. Pingback: PSYCHOSOCIAL
  66. Pingback: Cherekasi
  67. Pingback: djoker onlajn
  68. Pingback: generic viagra
  69. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  70. Pingback:
  71. Pingback:
  72. Pingback: viagra coupons
  73. Pingback: viagra generic
  74. Pingback: viagra pill
  75. Pingback: cheap viagra
  76. Pingback: cialis generic
  77. Pingback: cialis online
  78. Pingback: cialis 5mg
  79. Pingback: bitly
  80. Pingback: pharmacy online
  81. Pingback: cialis
  82. Pingback: dom 2
  83. Pingback: zoom-psykholog
  84. Pingback: Vratar
  85. Pingback: Cherkassy 2020
  86. Pingback: moskva-psiholog
  87. Pingback:
  88. Pingback: 323
  89. Pingback: 525
  90. Pingback: dom2-ru
  91. Pingback: Tenet Online
  92. Pingback: psy psy psy psy
  93. Pingback:
  94. Pingback:
  95. Pingback: CFOSPUK
  96. Pingback: MAMprEj
  97. Pingback: fgu0ygW
  98. Pingback: akmeologiya
  99. Pingback: dizain cheloveka
  100. Pingback: human-design-hd
  101. Pingback: tsoy
  102. Pingback: 44548
  103. Pingback: 44549
  104. Pingback: hod-korolevy-2020
  105. Pingback: HD
  106. Pingback: 38QvPmk
  107. Pingback: dzhonuikfilm4
  108. Pingback: 1444
  109. Pingback:
  110. Pingback: 232dfsad
  111. Pingback: join vk
  112. Pingback: vk login
  113. Pingback: svaty—7—sezon
  114. Pingback: svaty 7 sezon
  115. Pingback: tik tok
  116. Pingback: img
  117. Pingback: img1
  118. Pingback: 666
  119. Pingback: The Revenant 2021
  120. Pingback:
  121. Pingback: 2021
  122. Pingback: Human Design 2021
  123. Pingback: 777
  124. Pingback: Zakhar Berkut
  125. Pingback: 4569987
  126. Pingback: news news news
  127. Pingback: psy
  128. Pingback: psy2022
  129. Pingback: projectio-freid
  130. Pingback:
  131. Pingback: topvideos
  132. Pingback: video
  133. Pingback: Ukrainskie-serialy
  134. Pingback: site
  135. Pingback: top
  136. Pingback: chelovek-iz-90-h
  137. Pingback:
  138. Pingback: mazhor4sezon
  139. Pingback: filmfilmfilmes
  140. Pingback: gRh9UPV
  141. Pingback: 9-05-2022
  142. Pingback: TopGun2022
  143. Pingback: Xvideos
  144. Pingback: XVIDEOSCOM Videos
  145. Pingback: ivanesva
  146. Pingback: Netflix
  147. Pingback:
  148. Pingback: YA-krasneyu
  149. Pingback:
  150. Pingback:
  151. Pingback:
  152. Pingback:
  153. Pingback: psy online
  154. Pingback: Gz92uNNH
  155. Pingback: uels ukrain
  156. Pingback: do-posle-psihologa
  157. Pingback: DPTPtNqS
  158. Pingback: qQ8KZZE6
  159. Pingback: D6tuzANh
  160. Pingback: SHKALA TONOV
  161. Pingback: 3Hk12Bl
  162. Pingback: 3NOZC44
  163. Pingback: 01211
  164. Pingback: tor-lyubov-i-grom
  165. Pingback: film-tor-2022
  166. Pingback: hd-tor-2022
  167. Pingback:
  168. Pingback: JXNhGmmt
  169. Pingback: Psikholog
  170. Pingback:
  171. Pingback: Link
  172. Pingback:
  173. Pingback: bucha killings
  174. Pingback: War in Ukraine
  175. Pingback: Ukraine
  176. Pingback: web
  177. Pingback: Anonymous
  178. Pingback:
  179. Pingback: confeitofilm
  180. Pingback:
  181. Pingback: Dim Drakona 2022
  182. Pingback: 3qAIwwN
  183. Pingback: video-2
  184. Pingback:
  185. Pingback: 000-1
  186. Pingback:
  187. Pingback: x
  188. Pingback: 9xflix
  189. Pingback: free video
  190. Pingback: 123 movies
  191. Pingback: xxx
  192. Pingback: 2023

Comments are closed.